Guide

Managed IT vs break-fix: which is better?

What managed IT services actually are, how they differ from paying per call-out, and how to work out which suits your business.

There are two basic ways to pay for IT support. You can pay someone when something breaks, or you can pay someone to look after everything so that it breaks less. The first is called break-fix. The second is managed IT services.

This guide explains both, compares them honestly, and helps you work out which suits your business.

What are managed IT services?

With managed IT services, an outside provider takes ongoing responsibility for your IT in return for a fixed monthly fee, usually priced per user. In effect you get an IT department without employing one.

A managed service normally includes:

  • A help desk your staff can contact when they're stuck, during agreed hours.
  • Monitoring of computers, servers and networks, often around the clock, so problems are spotted before anyone notices.
  • Patching. Operating system and software updates tested and applied for you.
  • Security. Endpoint protection, email filtering, two-factor authentication and someone responding to alerts.
  • Backup and recovery, checked regularly by actually restoring from it.
  • Starters and leavers, accounts set up and closed properly.
  • Planning and advice. Knowing what's due for replacement, what licences you're paying for, and what's coming.
  • Supplier management. Chasing the broadband provider, the printer company and the software vendor on your behalf.

What is break-fix?

Break-fix is the traditional model. When something goes wrong, you ring an IT company or a freelancer, they fix it, and you pay for the time. Between calls, nothing is looked after: updates may or may not happen, nobody checks the backups, and nobody is watching for warning signs.

The real difference is incentives

On paper both models fix problems. The difference is what each supplier is paid for.

A break-fix supplier earns money when you have problems. They don't gain anything from preventing them, and the busier your IT keeps them, the better their month.

A managed provider earns the same fee whatever happens. Every problem they prevent is time they don't spend fixing it. Their interests line up with yours: fewer problems, less disruption.

How they compare

Break-fix Managed IT
Cost Unpredictable, nothing in a quiet month, a lot in a bad one Fixed monthly fee per user
Updates and patching Only if you ask Done for you, on a schedule
Security Usually nobody's job Monitored and managed
Backups Rarely tested Tested regularly
Response When they're free Agreed response times in writing
Knowledge of your setup Starts from scratch each visit Documented and kept up to date
Planning None Hardware and licence planning

The cost question

Break-fix looks cheaper because a good month costs nothing. But the costs that matter don't appear on the IT invoice:

  • Downtime. Staff who can't work while a problem waits to be fixed.
  • Emergency rates. Urgent call-outs and out-of-hours work cost more.
  • Incidents. A ransomware attack or failed server with no working backup can cost a small business tens of thousands of pounds, and some never recover. The government's Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2026 found that 43% of UK businesses had a breach or attack in the previous year, rising to 46% of small businesses and 65% of medium-sized ones.
  • Your time. The owner or office manager who ends up being the IT department.

Managed IT turns all of that into a predictable monthly figure. For most businesses with staff, it costs about the same as a modest break-fix bill, and removes the risk of the big one.

When break-fix can make sense

Being fair, break-fix isn't always wrong. If you're a sole trader with one laptop, keep good backups yourself, hold little customer data and could carry on with a phone if the laptop died, occasional paid help may be enough.

The balance tips quickly once you have staff, customer or child data, a server, or systems the business can't run without. At that point, nobody looking after things is the expensive option.

For one or two people, we offer Solo and Duo packages from £95 a month, which include the Microsoft 365 licences, security and backup. It's designed for exactly the businesses that have historically gone without.

Already have an IT person?

Managed IT doesn't have to mean replacing anyone. Co-managed IT is for businesses with their own IT person or team: the provider adds the tools, specialist knowledge and holiday cover, and the in-house person keeps ownership.

Where we stand

We only offer managed IT. We don't do ad-hoc call-outs, because we can't stand behind IT we're only allowed to look at when it's already broken. Our managed IT support starts at £30 per user per month, prices are published, and the notice period is 30 days.

If you'd like to see your current risk before deciding anything, start with a free exposure check.

Questions

What are managed IT services?

An outside provider looks after your IT on an ongoing basis for a fixed monthly fee. That usually covers help desk support, monitoring, updates, security, backups and dealing with your other IT suppliers, so you have a whole IT department without employing one.

What is break-fix IT support?

You call an IT company when something goes wrong and pay for the time it takes to fix. Nothing is looked after between calls.

Is managed IT more expensive than break-fix?

Month to month it costs more than a quiet month of break-fix. Over a year it's often cheaper, because there are fewer problems, no emergency rates, and less time lost. One serious incident, such as ransomware or a failed server with no working backup, usually costs more than years of managed support.

When does break-fix make sense?

For a single person with one computer, little sensitive data and no dependence on IT to trade, occasional paid help can be enough. As soon as you have staff, customer data or systems you can't work without, the risk usually outweighs the saving.

What's co-managed IT?

A version of managed IT for businesses that already have an IT person or team. The provider works alongside them, adding tools, specialist skills and cover for holidays. See co-managed IT support.

Want to know where your business stands?

Our free exposure check shows what an attacker can already see: leaked passwords, email spoofing and exposed systems. Fifteen minutes, nothing to install.

More guides